See the update at the bottom, because apparently this wasn't clear enough.Just read
this and felt profound shock.
Someone agrees with me!
When I was at school I was bullied mercilessly for years, driven to the point of suicide a couple of times because of it. You can see it clearly in all my school photographs from that period. I am so desperately trying to smile, to put on a happy face but all that comes out is a twisted, contorted grimace of fear and anger and depression because I'm sat next to the guy who has once again decided that he's going to make my life hell for the day.
I always feel sympathy for people who are bullied, but that's it. I don't feel more sympathy just because someone was bullied for a particular reason. I don't feel extra empathy because they're one of society's current designated victim groups. Gay people may have had it rough in the past. So did a little boy who's only crime was to be a little shy and a little quicker to show emotion than everyone else.
Much as I sympathise and understand the pain people go through when they're abused by others, I don't see why they should get a ribbon and a special day. Bullying is bullying is bullying; the reasons behind it are less important than the fact that the bully is taking pleasure in having power over another person's life, the fact that he's able to incite fear in them.
I didn't kill myself in the end but I was close, so very close several times. Other people bullied merely for being quiet, or red-haired, or having funny ears
have killed themselves because of it, but they don't get their ribbon and their special day for everyone to genuflect and absolve themselves of the "collective sin" of "hate". They die and they're forgotten by everyone except their family. Being gay is no more a valid reason for claiming special privilege than having a lisp or a funny accent, or fat lips, or squinty eyes, or the wrong sort of family background. Yet, do these get a ribbon? A special day? Collective soul-baring?
Why should any of it?
UPDATEI want to make it clear that this is nothing to do with any particular prejudice anyone might think I have against lgbt peeps, because I don't. I can't. I'd pretty much have to hate myself to have a prejudice against them because, and I know this might shock you, I am bisexual. For the record I wasn't bullied about this at school because it wasn't remotely obvious back then - I was just bullied about everything else. I have not made an issue of this fact in the past because I do not consider myself to be defined by who I might enjoy having sex with.
I do not believe that people should get extra "support" just because they're bullied for particular reasons. As I have attempted to point out, bullying is bullying, and it is a terrible thing, and every effort should be made to prevent it happening. I have never, ever said that bullying should be allowed to go on. I have
never advocated that bullying against some people is less painful than others. I have never said that people should just "man up" or deal with it.
My life was effectively destroyed for the better part of fifteen years because of what I experienced in school, and completely wiped out for the first six of those years. Between 1989 and 2005 I was, for all intents and purposes, spiritually and mentally dead and I made a lot of incredibly stupid decisions during that time. It's only the experience of my wedding that finally kicked me out of it. The idea of "manning up" is a joke to me.
I do believe with all my heart that creating special classes of bullying, special "hate crimes", creates inequality and resentment against the groups that have been designated as deserving of this special treatment, and mistreats everyone else who is not part of that designated group. It is unequal. It elevates certain people to a higher status than others without justification. Justification does not include what happens to people in other countries, either. Riding on the back of someone else's suffering is as bad as inflicting it on them in the first place.